Tell Me Lies, Tell Me Sweet Little Lies

Once I realized I wanted out of my relationship with Javier, the only thing stopping me from getting out was...well, him.

For months -- to be honest, it might have only been weeks -- I did everything I could think of to piss him off, to start fights so I could yell out in righteous indignation, "yeah, well too bad, this is over!" 

...Or something way cooler and stronger than that.

In all seriousness, though, I did everything I could think of. I smoked cigarettes, I went out "whoring" with my best friend (which is to say I went and hung out at her house or maybe went out to dinner, but in his eyes the only possible thing she and I could be doing was whoring around), I wore perfume to work, I demanded to use my car -- all in hopes of getting him mad enough to yell at me.

But it didn't work. I'm convinced he knew what I was up to and refused to take the bait. Wily bastard.

But then things changed -- again -- and I realized the game, such as it was, had changed.

I no longer remember the how or why, but I do remember standing in front of my bathroom mirror (maybe I was getting ready for work or something?) and Javier came in.  There was conversation, and it ended in a kiss -- only this wasn't a normal kiss. He took my bottom lip between his teeth, and held on. I tried to pull away, but he wouldn't let go. I whimpered, begged (as much as I could with my lip caught between his teeth), to no avail.

Finally, I dug my nails into his shoulder and he let go. As I checked my lip for blood, I looked up at him and I swear to God, the dude was smiling. Smiling. 

Taking pleasure from my pain, amusement from my panic. Satisfaction from knowing he still had the power.

It was in that moment that I realized that if I let this go on, he wouldn't stop at a playful nip. Next time, it could be my arm he was twisting...or my face he was bruising because I failed to fall in line with his agenda. Or, worse, simply because it was fun.

That is when I knew I had to end it, by any means necessary.

Turned out that tears were the means, as much as I loathed myself for resorting to them.

It was Memorial Day. My parents were out at a party, and I was alone watching Forget Paris while I folded laundry. Javier came home from wherever he'd been, and asked how I was doing (literally the most attentive thing he'd said or done in weeks). I looked at him, I thought about what I needed, and I let my system take over.

I cried.

Yep. I admit that I resorted to tears.

And you know what? It worked.

I set the laundry down and we went into my bedroom to talk. I told him I wasn't happy and I didn't feel like he cared about me. I told him I thought we should break up.  

There was a long pause, after which he sighed, looked at me and said, "I have to admit I don't feel the same way about you that I used to."

Riiiight. Like that ship hadn't sailed at least a year ago.

I'd like to be able to say that I gave him a week to get himself and his shit out of our house, but I was not that strong. I told him to take his time, and as spineless as that was, I felt good knowing that he understood that he needed to leave and that our relationship was over. I felt like I had climbed the mountain, reached the summit, and planted MY flag.

Oh, you silly, silly girl.

He might have been ready to end the relationship but he wasn't so quick to give up the perks.

First words out of his mouth after the agreement that he'd move out: "I guess this means you want your car back..."

No, asshat, you should keep it. I don't need my independence, and I really enjoy worrying about you getting arrested for driving my car without a license.

And, then, of course, when all was said and done, he figured what better way to seal this amicable end than to initiate sex?

Maybe he figured one last round for old time's sake? Or maybe he figured I'd get so wrapped up in the rapture that I'd forget I'd just told him to move out.

I'm betting on the latter.

Unfortunately, I didn't have the stones to tell him that, to his face, in the moment. Instead, I lied about having an "affliction" and scurried out of the room.

Even still...I did it. I ended it. I was about to be free.

At least that's what I told myself as I strolled out of the room. I couldn't have known it was nowhere near the end. 

Feels Like the End

Some time around my twenty-first birthday, I started to recognize that this relationship wasn't normal -- or healthy. I started to think about what my life would be like without Javier in it.

I'd slide open the closet door, look at my side, then look at his and let myself imagine what it would be like to have the whole thing to myself. A shiver would run through me, and I'd quickly slide it closed, just in case he came into the room and managed to read my mind.

I would write about it in my journal -- a Word document on a floppy disk I hid in my parents' office -- imagining what my life might look like without him in it. The places I could go, the things I could do. It was both exhilarating and terrifying. 

I was afraid to want it, so I never spoke about it. Hell, I was afraid to write about it in my journal -- not so much because I thought he might read it, but because saying the words, even to myself, made it real. And making it real meant having to do something, and I knew I wasn't ready.

So I went about my life, such as it was, getting unhappier by the day. He was growing more and more distant, which made me -- the very well programmed and conditioned part at least -- try harder to make him happy. He only grew colder, leaving me feeling desperate, frustrated, and terribly alone.

Late one night I sat in bed reading while he played his beloved video game. We were a foot and a half away from each other but the distance between us felt like a chasm. I couldn't take it. I just wanted to go to sleep.

Knowing I wouldn't be able to sleep with the video game going, I decided to leave him to it and try to sleep on the couch

I headed out of the room, then turned back, standing in the doorway. "Let me know when you're done, okay?" 

"What for?" His eyes never left the TV screen.

"So I can come back in and sleep."

He shrugged. "I really don't give a shit if you come back in here or not."

I couldn't tell you if more words were exchanged, if I stood there in stunned silence, or if I simply walked away. I only remember being curled up on the couch, sobbing, feeling like my insides had been ripped out. 

I couldn't take the pain, so I went upstairs to my parents' bedroom to find my mom. It was dark, but I knew she was awake, so I staggered into the room, breath hitching, hoping I wouldn't wake my dad.

Too late.

I told them what happened, and my mom held onto me while I cried. "He doesn't love me," I whimpered, as though it were a real surprise. I knew he didn't love me. But knowing he didn't care...that hurt unlike anything I'd ever felt before. 

I told them I knew it was time to break up with Javier, but I didn't know how. My dad, sitting on the edge of the bed, grumbled, "I can make it real easy."

"No, Daddy, don't, " I pleaded. I knew damn well my dad wasn't about to just go downstairs, yell "GET OUT" and wait for Javier to vacate the premises. What he had in mind involved violence and a hefty prison term. 

I didn't want my father in prison, and I didn't want any violence. But more than either of those things, I didn't want anyone else fighting my fight. 

The relationship was mine to end. I was ready.

Unfortunately, I had no idea how hard it would be to end it.

Wicked Games

Most of what I remember about the bulk of my two-and-a-half year relationship is a collection of moments. Feelings that are mixed up in the past and the present. Sometimes I am not sure if the moment is a memory or a reflection. Is it me, living the moment, at the tender age of 19 or 20, or is it me, now, with the wisdom of 43 years, looking back?

When I see myself standing in the foyer of our Oak Park home, staring at the closed door to the family room, paralyzed with fear, is that me? Or her? I don't know. I do know I'm afraid of opening the door. Because on the other side of it is Javier, with a giant white Valentine's Day bear, presented with flourish because I was upset with him for something and he wanted to make me feel better (which, of course, is to say that he was hoping a big stupid stuffed animal would make me forget he pissed me off or made me sad). And if I open that door, I'm letting him back in. I'm saying it's okay that he hurt me; it's okay for him to bribe me with gifts; to make me feel like a fool for having feelings. 

Yes, I opened the door. And again some time later, when he "braved" the rain to walk to our house, just to see me, and when I opened the door he said, "You see how much I love you?" Only that was a lie. A platitude, a fucking ploy to get me to let him in. He was banking on me getting so wrapped up in the words "I love you" that I'd forget everything else. 

Did I believe that he loved me? I wish I could answer that. I can't connect to any emotions other than fear and confusion. 

Looking back, though, I know he didn't. He was a sociopath and he was playing with me. Playing games with my sanity, because it was fun. 

For example, one night he left with my car, without telling me where was going (or, you know, inviting me, his live-in girlfriend, along), and stayed out well past midnight. He didn't have an actual driver's license, so every time he left with my car I worried something would happen and he'd end up in jail. The later it got, the more frantic I became. I couldn't sleep. I remember pacing my room at three a.m., wondering if anyone would even know to call me if he got pulled over, or got into an accident. I worried about what my parents would say once they found out I'd let him drive my car without a license. I worried about everything.

Sometime around 3:30, he came home. I was in bed, but not asleep, and I remember very clearly looking up to see him in the bedroom doorway, waiting. I flew out of bed in a rage, yelling at him for not calling me, for staying out all goddamn night, for having no consideration for me at all. He made a single lame excuse about not calling (he couldn't find a phone), I called bullshit and kept on yelling. And the whole time, he just watched me. No regret, no apologies. Only amusement.

He thought it was funny that I was mad. Funny. 

Another night, we got in a fight about something, and I was furious. Angrier than I'd ever been, maybe. He never yelled, just spoke to me quietly in condescending tones, which only made me yell even more. At one point in the argument, we went into our bedroom and closed the door in my face. He was done, the conversation was over, and I was left on the other side of the door, raging in a way I'd never raged before. I slammed my fist into the door, over and over, screaming at him, hating him, and he didn't even react. He didn't shout back telling me to shut up, he didn't open the door, he did nothing. He got the satisfaction of pissing me off, and I got a bruised hand and a battered psyche. 

It was all a game for him. How far could he push me? What new and inventive ways could he find to get a rise out of me? I played into it every time. He'd gone from punishing me for getting angry (like he'd done in the beginning) to making a game out of pissing me off. 

The man was making me crazy. He was making it so I never had solid ground to stand on, so I never knew which end was up, or even who I was. 

He was taking me apart.

Damage

My family and I moved from Oak Park to Villa Park in the summer of 1995. I got a job waiting tables at Chi-Chi's, and Javier got himself a job at the pizza place next door -- same restaurant as the one where we'd met, just a different location. I barely remember my time at that job, save for a few vague memories. The one night he had me followed, though, is still pretty clear in my head.

I got off work early one evening, and one of my co-workers asked for a ride. He was going to a friend's house that was right up the road and on my way home, so I dropped him off and headed home. When Javier got off work later that night, he came home and asked me how my night was. I told him it was fine, and he said, "so, you didn't give anyone a ride home?". 

I'm pretty sure my blood froze. I know my mind stopped working for a solid sixty seconds while I tried to process the information -- he'd been at work all night, so how could he know I gave anyone a ride home? Simple answer: he'd been spying on me.

And it wasn't the first time. I later found out that he knew about other things that had happened at work -- things he couldn't have known about unless he'd been watching me through the goddamn windows, or had people watching me and reporting back. 

He literally had eyes everywhere.

There was absolutely nothing I could hide from him. He'd already gone through my diary, my storage boxes, and now he was having me followed. I remember feeling angry that he didn't trust me, but deep down, there was fear. Was I afraid of what he'd find out? Was I afraid he'd leave? Was I afraid of something worse?

I still don't know the answer. I just know I was afraid. 

I left my job at Chi-Chi's after a few months and took a job as a bank teller. That job kept me afloat, emotionally, in ways I obviously couldn't have known at the time. But I was good at that job -- really good -- and it was the one thing he couldn't take away from me. In that building, I was strong, competent, confident, and relaxed. I had friends. I was me -- or, as much of me as I had left at that point.

It didn't take him long to become threatened, though. He started questioning my need to wear makeup to work, to wear perfume. He accused me of going out to meet other guys, when I was actually going in to the bank for an after-shift meeting. He looked for as many ways as he could to take away what little power I had. 

One of the easiest ways was for him to take control of my car. Again, it wasn't something we talked about or agreed upon. It just happened. One day that car was mine, and the next day I was borrowing my mom's minivan because he was off doing god-knows-what with my car. 

(Don't even get me started on the aching regret I carry, knowing my mother gave up a lot of her freedoms so I could still get around...I can't even think about that) 

I guess there were periods when I felt happy...I don't remember them anymore. I just have anecdotes, flashes of moments during which he chipped away at me, at all the things I thought I knew about myself. 

I'd always had issues with self-confidence, body image issues and stuff like that, but the one thing I got from Javier was a confirmation that I was attractive. Despite all the other crap he put me through, he managed to make me feel beautiful. I guess it was because he wanted me. Our mutual physical attraction was one thing that never came into question...until one night, as I was lying with him in bed in the most vulnerable way possible, feeling that wonderful afterglow, smiling as he traced a finger over my skin, and he said, "Why are you so fat?"

Well...twenty-plus years later, I still don't have sufficient words to describe what that felt like. 

But I do know the damage that was done in that single moment. And I'm still trying to recover from it.

Lessons Learned -- But Not the Way You'd Think

I don't remember how it happened, I just know that at some point, Javier had moved into our house. I never asked him, he never asked me, and I definitely did not ask my parents. We somehow went from him refusing to go into the house to us sneaking in late at night, crashing in the family room and getting him up and out before my dad left for work, to him just living there. 

I wish, so much, that I could go back and change that single event and spare myself two more years of disintegration and misery. But the story is what it is, and I can't undo a single bit of it.

Like many girls in high school, my bedroom walls had been papered with posters of the guys in my favorite bands (Motley Crue, Guns n' Roses, Poison, Metallica, etc.), but after I got back from my attempt at college, I took them all down. I was a grown up, and didn't need to have posters all over my walls. But I wasn't ready to get rid of them, so I carefully folded and put them away in a box, where they were safe.

Except nothing was safe with Javier living in our house; sleeping in my room. I came home one day and found him kneeling on the floor, with my journal open on the bed. He'd pulled it out from under my mattress and simply helped himself to my deepest thoughts dating back to when I was fourteen. When I came into the room, I asked him what he was doing and he looked at me and asked, "Who's Brandon?"

Brandon was a guy I'd worked with during my sophomore year, at a different restaurant. I'd had a huge crush on him at the time, so of course I wrote about him in my journal. The fact that my journal was private and the crush was more than three years old wasn't relevant for Javier, so he grilled me about Brandon, and about another guy Dave I'd had a brief thing for. He insisted I was still talking to them, that I still had feelings for them.

I was so busy defending myself against my adolescent -- and very personal --  feelings, musings, and wishes that I didn't have time to be angry with him for going through my things. I remember feeling a ball of panic and rage as I stood in that room, trying to make sense of such a personal attack.

And before I could grab a hold of that interrogation, Javier pulled out the posters I'd put away and laid into me about that. He didn't care that the posters were part of my past, he only cared that I kept them. They were pictures of other men, so why did I need them?  If they were off my walls, they should be thrown away. There was no room for argument.

So I took my posters, a valuable piece of my history, of my personality, and I threw them away.

I took my journal and, on the first day he wasn't around, hid it in a place I knew he wouldn't dare go looking. 

But the damage was done. My life was no longer mine, my history was slowly being erased, and I was losing pieces of myself every single day.

My best friend had come to work at the restaurant around the same time. I was thrilled, because I rarely got to see her, so this was our chance to hang out. But the thrill quickly turned into aggravation. Javier didn't like her, and she didn't like him. And I was caught in the middle.

She told me one day that her brother had been out at this all night diner in North Riverside (a town just south of where we lived) and he saw Javier in a booth with one of the bus boys from work and two women -- neither of whom were me. When I asked Javier about it, he denied everything, of course, and accused my best friend of being a whore. 

Yep. 

When I found out he was calling and sending flowers to one of the younger girls who worked up at the front desk (which was soul crushing, by the way. I can still remember the sinking in my chest, the weight of the sadness I felt at the time.), I waited until we were alone and asked him about it, as casually as I could. He didn't deny it. Instead he turned the whole thing on me and made me out to be the bad guy, so by the end of the conversation I was in tears, and I was apologizing to him. 

(As I write this, my stomach is turning itself into knots and I kind of want to go scream into a pillow.)

I decided that the best way to resolve the conflict was to quit my job. If I wasn't working there, he couldn't accuse me of flirting with the delivery drivers, or whatever transgressions he could invent. So I quit. He got to stay, though, and throw arrogant smirks at my best friend every chance he got.

I got to drive him to work every day and pick him up...but our relationship was still a secret so I couldn't just drop him off or pick him up outside the restaurant. Nope. I had to park two blocks away and wait for him. I was taking some courses at the local community college so I would usually pass the time studying until he came around the block and got in the car. It was a routine I was getting used to, even if I did think it was absurd.

One night, I was waiting for longer than usual, but I had my text book with me so I kept on studying, glancing up every few minutes to see if he was coming. Moments ticked by, and no Javier. I was starting to get annoyed, but I knew I wasn't allowed to be annoyed, so I just waited. I went back to my studies, and jumped out of my skin when he appeared from behind the car and slammed his hand on the window. 

When he came around to the passenger side, he started scolding me the second he opened the door. Why wasn't I paying attention? I shouldn't have been studying, anyone could have come up from behind and attacked me. How stupid could I be? And it didn't matter that I had been checking all of the mirrors every time I looked up to see if he was coming; the point was that I didn't see him. I had failed. Again.

You might be wondering if this was a set-up, and you'd be right. I'm fairly certain he had come out of work on time, came his usual way, saw me with my eyes on my book and decided to teach me a lesson. Well...frowned upon or not, I was fucking pissed.

Since I wasn't allowed to argue with him, the only way I could express my rage was to drive like an asshole. I was speeding down side streets, speeding down the main streets, but my mouth was firmly closed. Still, passive-aggression was actual aggression, so Javier told me to stop driving like that or he was going to walk home. At that point I didn't care if I'd ever see him again so I pulled over and let him out. He made some pithy comment to me about being safe before he closed the door and I sped off in a cloud of fury.

Of course, by the time I got home, the indignant rage had passed and all I had left was fear. Fear that he wouldn't come home, fear that he was gone for good. Fear that I had ruined everything. I remember crying to my mom and sister -- god bless them both for comforting me instead of telling me to kick his ass to the curb -- and then suddenly he was at the door. He was calm, quiet, and kind. Not contrite, because that would have meant he was wrong. No, he was just calm, as though that whole damn thing had never happened.

He'd won the game again. I'd learned two lessons that night, so of course he was smiling. Mission accomplished. Programming complete. 

Fool Me Once

There is a story I have wanted to tell for a long time, but never had the courage to share. It's not an uncommon story -- in fact it's probably more common than most of us realize. It's probably a story many people reading this can relate to, which is one of the reasons I hesitated to share it. Who wants to hear my story, when there are millions of women out there who've been through the same thing? What makes me and my experience so special?

Nothing makes it special, other than the fact that it's mine. It's part of my history, part of who I am, and maybe by sharing it I can help someone else -- how it helps isn't up to me, but if it changes just one person's view, or encourages just one person to demand better treatment, if it helps one person understand me a little bit more, then it's worth it.

Now comes the hard part. The soul-baring, vulnerable part of actually telling the story; of saying the words.*

I was still in high school when I met Javier. We both worked at a restaurant in Oak Park -- he was a cook/busboy and I worked the phones and the register. We worked in fairly close quarters, as the front counter and the kitchen were basically a single open space, so we interacted a lot. 

There was a slight language barrier, but I knew he was working hard at perfecting his English so communication wasn't a big deal, especially since it usually had to do with pizza orders and tables that needed to be cleaned.

After high school, I went away to college for a whopping six weeks and came back to work at the same restaurant. I started to befriend Javier and the other cooks -- we even went out to play pool a few times after work. Looking back, I have no idea why I thought that was a good idea. Or a safe idea. But I liked the attention. I liked being the only girl among them and I liked to flirt. 

Soon, it was just Javier and me playing pool, and it was even more thrilling because it felt like something "real". Having had no romantic relationships up to this point, having the attention of a cute guy -- who was a couple years older than me -- was exciting. The fact that I wasn't afraid of the attention made it even better. So, I hung out with him when he asked because it made me feel like I was important.

After we had sex for the first time -- which happened to be my first time ever -- I assumed what we had was an actual relationship, though as far as I know we never actually talked about it. It just became this thing we did, and since it felt normal to me, I never brought it up. I never asked for a label. I was happy to be inside the circle of people who'd had, or were currently in relationships. I could call a guy my boyfriend and mean it (not that I was allowed to, but still). 

But is it really a relationship if it can't be talked about it public? If our co-workers weren't allowed to know? If my friends weren't allowed to know? 

At the time, I didn't question it. I didn't question the fact that he never set foot inside our house. We'd go on dates to restaurants and parks that were way outside of Oak Park and then come back sit in my car outside the house for hours, but we never went inside. I guess the secrecy was part of the thrill for me, so I didn't even think to ask why.

Several months into our secret relationship, Javier and I went to a local park one night to hang out. I remember we were having a heated but friendly discussion about song lyrics -- I insisted he was wrong about the lyrics to "La Isla Bonita" by Madonna and he insisted I was wrong about the lyrics to "Come Undone" by Duran Duran -- and I thought it was funny that he was right about the English lyrics and I was right about the Spanish ones. We both laughed about it, and I remember feeling happy and content in that moment.

Oh, if only I'd known that would be one of the last times I could live in such ignorant bliss. 

When we were ready to leave, I realized my car keys were missing. I'd sworn they were right beside me on the playground equipment we'd been sitting on, but they were gone. I got up and hunted around -- in the dark, no less -- losing my mind because obviously we were stuck without the keys and we weren't supposed to be in the park at 1am anyway. A dozen thoughts about all the ways we could get into trouble scrambled around in my mind, and my panic was growing by the second. 

I no longer remember how I figured it out, but after all the frantic searching, I discovered that Javier had my keys in his pocket. The whole goddamn time. 

And he thought it was funny.

I was pissed. I made him give me the keys -- he thought it would be cute to play "keep away", because why not mess with the woman you've just pissed off? -- and went to the car. I wanted to drive home without him. I wanted to leave him in the park and let him figure out how to get to the damn train all by himself. But, lacking a solid spine, I let him in the car. I drove half a block, still mad as hell, and he made me stop the car. He wasn't going to put up with my anger, so he'd make his own way home. 

He got out of the car, leaving me speechless. And panicked. He was mad at me. Furious because I showed my temper, and instead of being pissed off about that, I found myself desperate to get him back in the car. I rolled down the window, driving alongside him as he made his way down the street, begging him to get in the car.

Begging. I was so afraid of him leaving me, of this being the end, that I literally forgot that he'd just fucking gas-lighted me and I had every right to be pissed off. I needed him to get back in the car, to kiss me and make up with me so I'd know I was okay. I was still wanted. 

And that, my friends, is how the next two years of my life began. Two years in which I gave away pieces of myself, again and again, because I didn't believe I could get anyone else. I was already convinced that I was lucky to have him, and that not having him was the worst thing that could happen to me.

I was so, so wrong.

Anyway, he got back in the car and I spent a ridiculous amount of time apologizing for my behavior. By the time I dropped him off at the train, all was right in my world. For a while, at least.

*In the interest of not making a novel out of this, I will continue this story in a series of posts, spread over the next several days.